Head to head
Two great answers to the same trip. Here's how they actually differ — places, neighborhoods and food, side by side.
The basics
New York packs eight-plus million people, Broadway's 41 theaters, and more Michelin stars than any other American city onto a few dense islands. A single day can run from a Met masterpiece to a Greenwich Village jazz set to 2 a.m. pastrami on the Lower East Side.
Los Angeles sprawls across beaches, canyons, and freeway interchanges, hiding world-class art collections, America's best street tacos, and working film backlots in plain sight. Treat it as a collection of villages — Venice, Silver Lake, Hollywood, Downtown — rather than one city, and it clicks.
Round 1
Top three from each city — every one rated 4.5+ stars by thousands of travelers.
New York
The Plaza
Midtown (Central Park South)
The St. Regis New York
Midtown East
Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown
Tribeca
Los Angeles
The Beverly Hills Hotel
Beverly Hills
Hotel Bel-Air
Bel-Air
Chateau Marmont
West Hollywood
Round 2
Top three from each city — every one rated 4.5+ stars by thousands of travelers.
New York
Le Bernardin
Midtown West
Katz's Delicatessen
Lower East Side
Peter Luger Steak House
Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Los Angeles
Providence
Hollywood
Bestia
Arts District
République
Hancock Park (La Brea)
Round 3
Top three from each city — every one rated 4.5+ stars by thousands of travelers.
New York
The Dead Rabbit
Financial District
Employees Only
West Village
Attaboy
Lower East Side
Los Angeles
Death & Co
Arts District
EP & LP
West Hollywood
Tiki-Ti
Los Feliz
Round 4
Top three from each city — every one rated 4.5+ stars by thousands of travelers.
New York
Central Park
Manhattan
The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Upper East Side
Empire State Building
Midtown
Los Angeles
Griffith Observatory
Griffith Park (Los Feliz)
The Getty Center
Brentwood
Santa Monica Pier
Santa Monica
The honest verdict
Dig into the full guides and let the places decide for you.